Topic: Books....
Who Killed Daniel Pearl? by Bernard-Henri Levy
Remember Wall Street Journal reporter Dan Peral who was beheaded on-camera by militants while he was reporting from Karachi? Mass media wrote about Pearl and his investigative journalism and speculated that he was killed because he got too close to power-that-may-be and was about blow lid on some sensational stuff. So, he was clipped.
That is true but there is more to what meets the eye. French best selling author, Levy, tries to piece together things and sheds some new light not only Pearl's death but also on political realities of that time in Pakistan. He builds a theory that somehow ISI was responsible for his death in an attempt to discredit Musharaf who had alienated certain powerful faction within ISI. In order to understand this, Levy gives some good supporting material documenting tension between native Punjabis and Mohajirs(who went from India) during partition. Mushraf is a prominent Mohajir. You may remember during his visits to India he made it a point to go back to the place where he was born and brought his aging mother also next time.So, author ends wondering who was at the power at that time? Musharaf or rogue faction of ISI?
Levy who was in the sub continent during the liberation of Bangladesh, uses his past contacts to gain access to Indian intelligence agency RAW and comes up with some interesting stuff about Omar Sheikh and Masood Azar, two prominent Jaish-E-Mohammad militants. They have a very interesting story. These two were arrested and jailed by India while they were busy with subversive activities in Kashmir. In 1999, their followers hijacked Indian Airlines flight from Nepal and took it to Kandahar which was then under the control of Taliban. Taliban was party to all this. Although they tried to act neutral and I think even levied money from India for having allowed the plane to land and remain there for few days. Omar and Masood were handed over by India to gain the release of hostages and that's how the drama ended. Author touches upon this because Omar was arrested by Pakistani authorities as the main accuses in the murder of Pearl. Under pressure from US, Musharaf also came down heavily on militant organizations and Masood was also jailed. That is the reason why fundamentalists were pissed with president and he allegedly survived half a dozen of assassination attempts. Some publicized and some not.
Author speculates that Omar is not the real culprit. He has been scapegoated or has volunteered to protect some other powerful interest in return from quick release. Author does not divulge much information about renegade group within ISI that he holds responsible for Pearl's death. It appears that author is privy to all that info but chose not rock the boat too hard and devotes good last 30 % which is not interesting at all.
Author cites former IB chief AK Doval who was then a deputy head in RAW. Doval narrates how prisoners for hostage exchange took place in Kandahar. It is not known to many that elite commandos were taken by India but there was no solid plan to use them. Then God knows what they were doing. I do not think India would have taken a chance when top minister like Jaswant Singh and several passengers were involved to make a rescue a real risky job. Anyways....
First half is a page tuner because it is really captivating. Remainder is also page turner because it gets boring once you know that some faction within ISI was responsible and the author goes no where and does not share the details....
Now on a different topic...AK Doval was in news sometime back. After working in RAW, he became the head of IB (Intelligence Bureau IB - akin to FBI). A team of crime branch officers from Bombay intercepted a car in Delhi. Their target was Vicky Malhotra, right hand man of Chhota Rajan, Indian mob boss, operating out of some other country. They were surprised to find out another passenger along with Malhotra in the car. It was none other than Doval. Both men were going some where after having had breakfast in some hotel in Delhi. What was a retired IB chief doing with a mob man? Media speculated quite correctly that Chhota Rajan was developed to counter other mob boss Dawood Ibrahim. Since Dawood was being sheltered by ISI, Indian intelligence agencies chose to support Chhota Rajan. In that context, it was not unusual for IB officers to hang around with mafia men belonging to Rajan gang. It was during one such hang outs, Bombay cops were kinda confused with Doval with Malhotra. It is different story that media reports claimed that after realizing who they had in their hands, Bombay cops respectfully let Doval go and took only Vicky Malhotra with them to Bombay. But, it was not before Doval made some calls. All from media reports. Who knows what is the truth behind all this?
Cheers!
Posted by Mahesh
at 5:28 PM EDT
Updated: Monday, 12 June 2006 10:47 PM EDT